2026-04-21 consolidated venue-transfer denial chronology
A single Consolidated Order issued by Judge James A. Gibbons on Apr. 21, 2026 denied Motions to Transfer Venue in three unrelated Tufano cases at once -- C008 (BBB), C020 (Reddit), and C024 (United Healthcare) -- on the grounds that the motions did not reflect proper service and that no mechanism exists for a plaintiff-initiated venue transfer.
The Consolidated Order itself, directly reviewed via the LPA Prothonotary portal, quoted verbatim on the reasoning for denial.
Research assessment
This is a single shared procedural order spanning three otherwise-unrelated disputes (DSP015/DSP017/DSP013); it is recorded once here rather than as three separate ad hoc chronologies, and each affected case's own dispute page also carries the corresponding timeline row.
Important caveat
This order did not rule on the merits of any of the three underlying cases -- only on the plaintiff-initiated venue-transfer motions. All three cases remain open beyond this order.
Cases in this sequence
Timeline
A Consolidated Order (James A. Gibbons, P.J.) ruled on three of Tufano's Motions to Transfer Venue at once -- 2025-CV-3928 (C008), 2025-CV-6513 (C020), and 2025-CV-9609 (C024) -- finding the motions did not reflect proper service on any defendants and that no mechanism exists for a plaintiff to accomplish such a transfer. All three motions were denied.
Source — ic-access.com ↗The same Consolidated Order (see LT100) denied C020's Motion to Transfer Venue alongside C008's and C024's.
Source — ic-access.com ↗The same Consolidated Order (see LT100) denied C024's Motion to Transfer Venue alongside C008's and C020's.
Source — ic-access.com ↗