Pennsylvania state and federal case relationships
16 researched relationships. Confirmed removals are treated as the same underlying action; parallel or repeated-party cases remain separate unless a source establishes otherwise.
| Relationship | State case | Federal case | Same action | Confidence | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Confirmed removal | 2025-04277 | 3:25-cv-01175 | Yes | High | Federal removal record identifies Lackawanna 25-CV-4277. |
| Confirmed removal | 2025-05469 | 3:25-cv-01558 | Yes | High | Federal removal record identifies Lackawanna 2025-CV-5469. |
| Confirmed removal | 2025-05634 | 3:25-cv-01574 | Yes | High | Federal removal record identifies Lackawanna 25-5634. |
| Confirmed removal | 2026-00637 | 3:26-cv-00542 | Yes | High | Federal Notice of Removal identifies Lackawanna 2026-CV-637. |
| Confirmed removal | 2026-00838 | 3:26-cv-01266 | Yes | High | Filing 1 expressly removes Lackawanna County case 26-cv-838; on May 27 the removed federal action was consolidated into C061. |
| Confirmed removal | 2026-01160 | 3:26-cv-00835 | Yes | High | Federal Notice of Removal identifies Lackawanna 26-CV-1160. |
| Confirmed removal | 2026-01161 | 3:26-cv-00840 | Yes | High | Federal Notice of Removal identifies Lackawanna 2026-01161. |
| Confirmed removal | 2026-01525 | 3:26-cv-00939 | Yes | High | Federal Notice of Removal identifies Lackawanna 26-CV-01525. |
| Same-day parallel proceeding; later federal consolidation | 2026-00838 | 3:26-cv-00396 | No | High | C061 was an original federal action filed Feb. 17, 2026 against Paul Saladino and Heart & Soil. C032 is recorded the same day; after C032 was removed as C074, the court consolidated C074 into C061. |
| Same-day parallel original complaints (pleading comparison pending) | 2025-05793 | 3:25-cv-01400 | No | Medium | The Lackawanna compilation and federal docket share the same date/title context; federal Filing 1 is an original complaint, not a removal. |
| Same-day parallel original complaints (pleading comparison pending) | 2025-06513 | 3:25-cv-01495 | No | Medium | Both are Tufano v. Reddit filings dated Aug. 13, 2025; federal Filing 1 is an original complaint, not a removal. |
| Cross-forum same-dispute chronology | 2024-06106 | 3:24-cv-01117 | No | Medium | Federal Miller case was filed July 8, 2024 and had an R&R recommending dismissal on Aug. 28, six days before the Lackawanna Miller case was filed. |
| Later federal filing with overlapping Miller defendants | 2024-06106 | 3:26-cv-02134 | No | Medium | Later federal Miller action again names Amos Miller, Fox News and GiveSendGo among defendants. |
| Later federal filing with same Crispino defendants | 2024-06107 | 3:26-cv-02135 | No | Medium | Later federal action again names Leo Crispino and Crispino's refrigeration/air-conditioning company. |
| Later federal filing against BBB | 2025-03928 | 3:26-cv-02132 | No | Medium | Later federal action is again Tufano v. BBB. |
| Later federal filing against United Healthcare | 2025-09609 | 3:26-cv-02136 | No | Medium | Later federal action is again Tufano v. United Healthcare. |
The Lackawanna Public Inquiries interface remains difficult to automate. Where direct state PDFs are unavailable, federal removal records and orders are used conservatively to verify relationships.